⭐ የእኔ አፍሪካ
EN | FR | ES | PT | 中文 | عربي | SW | HA | አማ | TWI

ቅዳሜ 21 ኖቬምበር 2026

የዚህ ገጽ ምናሌዎች እና ርዕሶች በGoogle Translate በማሽን የተተረጎሙ ናቸው፤ ስህተቶች ሊኖሯቸው ይችላሉ። ጽሑፎቹ በአሳታሚው ቋንቋ ይቆያሉ።

Opinion & Analysis › Economics

OpinionEconomics

GHANA'S BUDGETS AND THE ART OF NOT UNDERSTANDING THEM

Ghana's 2027 Budget promises a US$10 billion New Economy. Read backwards, the numbers tell a different story.

By · · 10 min read

15 min listen
0:0015:11
DownloadRead by an AI voice
ShareWhatsAppXFacebookLinkedInTelegram
Traders and shoppers on the street outside Makola Market in Accra
Photo: Benggriff / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

I used to watch Kwasi Botchwey, then the Secretary for Finance and Economic Planning, read the budget at my friend's house.

There was only one station then, Ghana Television (GTV), and when the budget came on, the whole country tuned in. We sat in front of the set like men at a cup final, nodding at the right moments, and I pretended I understood what he was saying. I did not. Neither did my friend. Botchwey spoke in long, immaculate sentences, in an English that had gone to Yale and come back carrying a briefcase, in numbers with more zeros than the national lottery, and with roughly the same odds of any of them landing in our pockets. We watched anyway, because in Ghana the budget is not a document. It is a ritual. It is national theatre, in which the man in charge of the nation's money faces the nation, speaks at length, and makes the future sound as if it has already arrived.

Dr. Cassiel Ato Forson, who read the 2027 Budget in Parliament on Thursday, November 12, is not Kwasi Botchwey. He does not have the professorial cadence that made complicated things sound even more complicated. But he has inherited the same stage, the same applause lines and the same problem, and one is left to wonder whether the applause, too, has been given its own line in the estimates.

The problem is this. Year after year, our governments produce policies that hardly touch the lives of ordinary people, and they present them so romantically and beautifully that we almost forgive them.

And the ordinary Ghanaian is not listening anyway. I dare say that ninety percent of this country never pays attention to what is in the budget, and in the Botchwey years the only thing we took from his reading was whether the price of petrol would go up or not. They hear the applause, they catch the headline about fuel or tax, and they go back to the business of surviving. That is not ignorance. It is experience, acquired at considerable expense and, unlike the budget, fully paid for in cash.

So let us do what Ghanaians rarely do. Let us read the budget backwards.

First, what happened to the last sermon

In November 2025, the government announced its reset. It would spend GH¢302.5 billion and collect GH¢268.1 billion. The gap of GH¢34.4 billion would be borrowed, and this, we were told, was discipline. The theme was Resetting for Growth, Jobs and Economic Transformation.

Months later, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) checked the books.

The government had planned to spend GH¢172.5 billion by June. It spent GH¢136.9 billion. A full GH¢35.6 billion, one-fifth of the half-year budget, was not stolen, not saved and not invested. It was simply not spent.

Which raises a question the Minister did not trouble Parliament with that evening. If that money was borrowed or collected and then not spent, where is it now? In which account is it sitting, under whose signature, and who, precisely, has been appointed to mind it while the roads it was meant to build go on waiting? Money, unlike a manifesto, does not simply evaporate; it is either somewhere, or it is with someone, and the taxpayer who supplied it is entitled to know which.

Look closely at what was left unspent, because a government reveals itself less by what it spends than by what it fails to spend.

Capital expenditure, which is the official name for roads, classrooms, hospital beds and culverts, the things a citizen can touch, fell short by GH¢14.38 billion, or 39.3 percent. Arrears clearance, meaning the money owed to Ghanaian contractors who had already built the roads and were waiting, hat in hand, to be paid, fell short by 61.8 percent. One would like to know whether those contractors have been invited to accept fiscal prudence in settlement of their invoices, and whether their own banks have agreed to accept it in settlement of theirs.

The first quarter had already told the story. JoyNews Research calculated that the government executed only 73 percent of its own budget in those three months, the weakest first quarter since 2017. Of GH¢5.3 billion budgeted for foreign-funded projects, only GH¢0.6 billion was released. Was the remainder ever drawn down, or does it still sit with the lenders awaiting some paperwork of ours, and if it was drawn down, in which drawer has it been resting since?

Revenue missed too. GH¢126.14 billion was to be collected by June; GH¢124.78 billion came in. Non-tax revenue fell short by about GH¢2.63 billion, GH¢1.43 billion of it from oil dividends and profits alone, which suggests that even the oil, in its own modest way, declined to take the budget at its word.

And so we arrive at the perfect Ghanaian miracle: a government praised for fiscal prudence because it failed to do what it said it would do. It borrowed less only because it built less. Prudence, in this arrangement, is merely the name we give to the classroom that was never roofed, and the praise is collected long before anyone thinks to ask where the unspent money went to live.

Then came the new sermon

On November 12, 2026, Dr. Forson returned to Parliament with a new title and bigger numbers: The New Economy, New Ghana, Jobs and Prosperity.

Spending: GH¢375 billion on the same basis as last year's GH¢302.5 billion, or GH¢389.2 billion in cash terms.
Revenue: GH¢323.4 billion, up from GH¢268.1 billion.
The gap: GH¢51.9 billion on last year's basis, up from GH¢34.4 billion, a rise of half in a single year. In cash terms, GH¢65.8 billion will have to be borrowed.

Last year's smaller gap was called discipline, so we must presume that this year's larger gap is discipline that has discovered ambition, and we may ask the Minister, with the courtesy the occasion deserves, at what size a deficit stops being disciplined and starts being simply a deficit.

On top of this foundation sits a cathedral: a US$10 billion New Economy programme over four years, GH¢30 billion of it in 2027 alone, resting on eight pillars that, if you do not think too hard, describe the Ghana we have all been waiting for.

There is $3 billion for commercial agriculture to end rice imports, and $2.2 billion for energy, including a new plant at Kafodzidzi meant to cut the cost of generating power from about 16 cents a kilowatt-hour to 8 cents. There is $1.5 billion for critical minerals so that we stop exporting raw gold and bauxite, and a billion dollars each for textiles, medicines and tourism. There is $300 million for technology, for a National Artificial Intelligence Centre and for upgrading village masts from second-generation (2G) to fourth-generation (4G) mobile networks.

And there are dates, at last, to make the dream sound like a contract. By December 2027, 70 percent of small-scale gold will be refined here. By 2028, there will be no raw small-scale gold exports, and half of all cocoa, manganese and bauxite will be processed locally. By 2030, there will be no commercial rice imports at all, all cocoa will be processed at home, and no raw bauxite or manganese will leave our shores. One cannot help noticing that the deadlines grow bolder in exact proportion to their distance from the present, which is a fine quality in a prophecy and a rather worrying one in a budget.

On paper, it is the most nationalist, most sensible, most patriotic budget ever written.

On paper.

And paper, it must be said, has always been the most obedient of our national resources, since it never asks to be paid and never complains when the road it describes fails to appear.

Here the common-sense economist clears his throat

The ordinary Ghanaian, the trotro driver, the tomato seller, the graduate sitting at home, understands three things the Ministry of Finance has never understood. You cannot create wealth by spending money you do not have. You cannot make things cheap by banning the cheap things. And you cannot build an economy out of eight pillars chosen by a committee.

Ludwig von Mises called this the calculation problem, and it sits at the heart of this budget.

How does the Minister know that $3 billion belongs in agriculture and not $6 billion? How does he know that textiles deserve a billion dollars and not nothing? How does he know that Ghana needs an Artificial Intelligence centre more than it needs cold storage for tomatoes in Techiman? And if the Ministry possesses such exact knowledge of where money ought to go, how did it manage, only last year, to leave one-fifth of its own half-year budget sitting unspent?

He does not know. He cannot know. Value is not discovered in a budget statement. It is discovered by thousands of entrepreneurs risking their own money, failing and trying again. Replace that discovery with a pillar and you do not get development. You get malinvestment.

Consider the promise of 8-cent power. If electricity could be produced and sold profitably at 8 cents, private companies would be falling over themselves to sell it at 9 cents and undercut the Electricity Company of Ghana (ECG). They do not, and the reason is not the absence of a pillar. It is that the price of power in Ghana is political, collection is political and the contracts are political. A $2.2 billion state plant built with borrowed money does not remove the cost. It moves it from your light bill to your tax bill and your inflation bill. You will still pay. You simply will not see where. Should we not ask why no investor has yet offered to make this famous 8-cent power with his own money, and what the Ministry knows about the economics of electricity that the people who actually sell it have somehow failed to learn?

Consider the rice ban. Every import-substitution regime ends the same way. The price of the banned good rises. The poorest household, which spends most of its income on food, pays more. And the politically connected importer whose licence is tied to local purchase grows rich. That is not industrial policy. It is rent-seeking with a Ghana flag on it, and one would be grateful to learn, before 2030 arrives, who exactly will be holding those licences.

Consider the borrowing. GH¢65.8 billion in 2027 alone. Borrowed from where? From the same pool of savings the seamstress in Cape Coast would have used to buy a second sewing machine, and the shop owner in Tamale would have used to restock. When government borrows at home, it keeps interest rates high. Then the Minister creates a pillar called "affordable finance" to cure the high interest rates his own borrowing caused. He is pouring water into a bucket he has punctured himself. And if part of this year's borrowing, like so much of last year's money, ends up borrowed but not spent, will the Minister tell the seamstress in which account her sewing machine is now sleeping, and who is being paid to keep it company?

And consider the most painful numbers of all: GH¢92.6 billion for salaries and GH¢61 billion for interest on old loans. That is GH¢153.6 billion, about 40 percent of the entire budget, gone before a single block is laid or a single child gets a desk. The GH¢61 billion in interest is not a line item. It is the invoice for all the beautiful budgets that came before, and the only open question is in which future year the invoice for this one, the most beautiful of them all, will arrive.

What the budget teaches

Kwasi Botchwey, for all the grammar I could not follow in my friend's sitting room, understood one thing we have forgotten. A budget is not about how much you promise to spend. It is about what your spending teaches people to do.

Too many of our budgets have taught Ghanaians to wait. To wait for government. To wait for a pillar. To wait for a plant in Kafodzidzi.

The market, left alone, teaches people to act.

The 2027 Budget is not a lie. It is something worse. It is a sincere, beautifully written, ten-billion-dollar plan to do what Ghanaians would do for themselves if government took less, borrowed less, banned less and got out of the way.

And ask the one question no budget statement has yet thought to answer: when the money is borrowed or collected in your name and then not spent, where does it go, and who is minding it?

So do not watch the document. Watch the dust.

Watch whether the road to your farm is tarred by June.

Watch whether your ECG bill falls, or whether it rises.

Watch whether your child sits at a desk next September.

Those three things have never been to Yale. They do not speak in grammar.

Which is precisely why they have never learned to lie.

Joseph A. Sampson is the Founder and Publisher of AfricaFrontPage.

GhanaEconomics

ShareWhatsAppXFacebookLinkedInTelegram

Have an argument to make? Write for AfricaFrontPage ›

More Opinion & Analysis